Gulf Coast - A Journal of Literature and Fine Arts
Contact Gulf Coast Magazine
View Artwork
Return to the Table of Contents


A Heap of Broken Images
an introduction by Sean Bishop
A Heap of Broken Images

       In the last decade, comic book art has lost some of the stigma associated with greasy-haired
figurine collectors, becoming more and more respected in the larger artistic and literary communities.
The conventional narrative for this shift typically begins with seminal figures of alternative and
underground comics from the 1970s and ’80s—R. Crumb, Harvey Pekar, etc.—then traces the path
from Art Spiegelman’s Maus (1980–’91) and Alan Moore’s Watchmen (1986–’87) through later
benchmarks in the movement like Joe Sacco’s Palestine (1996), Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis (2000),
and Chris Ware’s Jimmy Corrigan, the Smartest Kid on Earth (2000). These, at least, are the books
most likely to turn up on syllabi at the growing handful of schools where courses on comic book
history and “the graphic novel” are offered. They reflect an increasing desire among many comic
book artists, writers, and readers to avoid campiness, and to strive to address more complicated
themes than did previous generations.
       Although these books and authors deserve their places in the emerging canon of “literary” comic
books, we put unnecessary limitations on the form if we use them as our sole models. Chief among
these limitations is an over-dependence on narrative; with the notable exception of some of Crumb’s
work, all of the books listed above have cohesive storylines. Even the term “graphic novel”—which
is increasingly (and inaccurately) used to distinguish literary comic books from their more traditional,
superhero-centered brethren—implies that plot and narrative are somehow intrinsic to the comic book
form. This simply isn’t the case. In a number of ways, in fact, comic books more closely resemble
poems than novels: they use text sparingly; they frequently “break” lines for dramatic or tonal effects;
and much like lyric poetry, comic books often juxtapose images to create meaning, without any clear
narrative or syntactic relationship between the images they present. Recently the Poetry Foundation,
in its “Poem as Comic Strip” series, has tried to demonstrate the capabilities of the comic strip as a
poetic form. But this effort is still young, and while “graphic novel” has become a household term,
“graphic poem” remains outside the popular lexicon.
       When Gulf Coast began brainstorming a feature of comic book art, we decided to highlight the
lesser-known lyric strengths of the form. What better way to do this, we thought, than to commission
a graphic interpretation of The Waste Land? Not only is the poem famously non-narrative, but it
also shares some interesting affinities with comic books. Eliot’s poem is a sort of pastiche—its
method of construction is typically described by quoting the poem itself: “a heap of broken images”—
and this description applies even more literally to comic book art. We also felt confident that a graphic
response to / rehashing of The Waste Land would nicely complement the poem’s original project: Eliot
resampled, distorted, and welded together a plethora of literary and pop-cultural sources to write his
poem—Tennyson, ragtime lyrics, etc.—thereby providing new contexts for the works he cited. The next
logical step, we thought, would be to resample The Waste Land itself; just as Eliot cobbled together a
poem using quotations from Shakespeare’s plays, Hindu prayers, and Arthurian legend, we would use
The Waste Land to make a comic book. But who was up to that task?
       After a lot of searching, we found Scotland-based artist Ben Powis, whose portfolio included
traditional narrative comic books as well as covers for Moby Dick, Journey to the Center of the Earth,
and the Selected Poems of Wilfred Owen. We admired Powis’s gritty yet fantastic illustration style—
a persistent dark whimsy in his work—and these characteristics are apparent in his interpretation of
Eliot’s poem. Powis’s waste land is not the wreckage of the Great War, but an otherworldly desert
populated by insects and anthropomorphic trees. His “Marie” rides a toboggan down a barren mountain,
wearing a reaper-like hood. And for Powis, “the hanged man” of Madame Sosostris’s tarot reading is
not suspended by his foot, as in the traditional tarot deck, but by his throat. And yet Powis tempers
the added darkness of these innovations with his almost children’s-book-like illustration style.
       What follows is only the first section of The Waste Land, “The Burial of the Dead.” We regret that
we can’t give you more right now. It’s our hope, though, that these pages will provoke a richer
discussion about the capabilities and limitations of the comic book form, and that Gulf Coast might
be able to continue this project—and this conversation—in issues to come. Enjoy!
Gulf Coast: A Journal of Literature and Fine Arts Centerforward Web Services Squidz Ink Design